The Q* Index: A Useful Global Measure of Dementia Screening Test Accuracy?

BACKGROUND/AIMS Single, global or unitary, indicators of test diagnostic performance have intuitive appeal for clinicians. The Q* index, the point in receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve space closest to the ideal top left-hand corner and where test sensitivity and specificity are equal, is one such measure. METHODS Datasets from four pragmatic accuracy studies which examined the Mini-Mental State Examination, Addenbrooke's Cognitive Examination-Revised, Montreal Cognitive Assessment, Test Your Memory test, and Mini-Addenbrooke's Cognitive Examination were examined to calculate and compare the Q* index, the maximal correct classification accuracy, and the maximal Youden index, as well as the sensitivity and specificity at these cutoffs. RESULTS Tests ranked similarly for the Q* index and the area under the ROC curve (AUC ROC). The Q* index cutoff was more sensitive (and less specific) than the maximal correct classification accuracy cutoff, and less sensitive (and more specific) than the maximal Youden index cutoff. CONCLUSION The Q* index may be a useful global parameter summarising the test accuracy of cognitive screening instruments, facilitating comparison between tests, and defining a possible test cutoff value. As the point of equal sensitivity and specificity, its use may be more intuitive and appealing for clinicians than AUC ROC.